QUARTERBACK STUFF

Updated; 9/23/26

I decided to add a little bit here, with each manager’s TOP 5. Can you guess yours? Josh couldnt.

TOP 5 MOST STARTED

Chris Dave Matt Trigger
1 Josh Allen (72) A. Rodgers (98) P. Mahomes (66) Matt Ryan (53)
2 M. Stafford (21) Brett Favre (22) P. Rivers (44) Tom Brady (46)
3 Big Ben (20) J. Herbert (22) Russ Wilson (16) D. Culpepper (31)
4 Kurt Warner (20) Drew Brees (21) Tom Brady (16) P. Manning (30)
5 C. Palmer (20) Tony Romo (19) 6-Way Tie (15) L. Jackson (22)
Jones Kronner Kasier Jim
1 Tom Brady (45) M. Stafford (60) Eli Manning (59) Big Ben (43)
2 Tony Romo (31) D. McNabb (51) Jay Cutler (31) Tom Brady (31)
3 Dak Prescott (28) P. Rivers (45) Big Ben (26) Hasselbeck (26)
4 Brett Favre (25) J. Herbert (30) Drew Brees (25) Drew Brees (24)
5 Drew Brees (19) K. Murray (27) S. McNair (21) Brett Favre (18)
Josh Ryan Kyle Shaun
1 Kurt Warner (37) Drew Brees (72) Tom Brady (45) Drake Maye (11)
2 L. Jackson (23) A. Rodgers (34) Russ Wilson (16) J. Daniels (2)
3 Drew Brees (21) Jared Goff (24) M. Stafford (11) Sam Darnold (1)
4 3-Way Tie (15) Joe Burrow (17) Jared Goff (8) N/A
5 N/A Tom/Stafford (15) Geno Smith (8) N/A

Crazy how many 15’s are in there – start someone all year, playoffs included, and then never speak to them again…

Most Top 5 Appearances;

  1. Brady/Brees – 7
  2. Stafford/Favre – 4
  3. Rodgers/Roethlisberger – 3

Matt Schaubb has the fewest total starts (36) of any retired players to make a Top 5 (Josh’s tie) and he just missed making it twice. He was edged out by just 1 start on Jon’s list, landing behind Brees 19-18.

CURRENT MANAGERS

QUARTERBACK CT DA BK JJ MS MA MK JK RK JT KS SK TOTAL
Tom Brady 7 15 45 46 16 15 15 31 45 235
Drew Brees 9 21 19 15 15 25 21 72 24 221
Aaron Rodgers 98 16 16 15 34 1 180
Matthew Stafford 21 3 60 4 13 15 1 15 11 143
Eli Manning 15 10 15 12 59 2 16 129
Phillip Rivers 15 45 6 44 1 12 1 124
Matt Ryan 17 2 17 53 15 7 111
Brett Favre 1 22 25 16 15 9 18 106
Big Ben 20 6 1 3 5 26 43 104
Patrick Mahomes 3 15 16 68 102
Russ Wilson 15 12 1 2 1 16 11 10 2 16 86
Donovan McNabb 7 8 51 5 14 85
Josh Allen 70 10 80
Peyton Manning 8 7 15 30 15 75
Tony Romo 15 19 31 9 74
Lamar Jackson 15 22 12 23 72
Dak Prescott 10 26 1 19 11 67
Kurt Warner 20 5 37 62
Michael Vick 16 4 11 10 11 5 57
Justin Herbert 21 29 3 2 55
Matt Hasselbeck 10 2 9 1 3 26 51
Mark Bulger 1 15 15 10 1 7 49
Jared Goff 10 1 1 4 24 8 48
Cam Newton 8 16 5 13 42
D. Culpepper 5 31 4 40
Kyler Murray 27 13 40
Jay Cutler 1 5 1 31 1 39
Joe Burrow 5 2 15 17 39
Kirk Cousins 2 6 4 10 9 7 38
M. Schaubb 18 3 15 36
Joe Flacco 6 1 2 1 5 13 3 4 35
Aaron Brooks 4 10 14 5 1 34
Jalen Hurts 9 9 10 6 34
R. Gannon 15 18 1 34
Trent Green 13 1 1 15 30
Jon Kitna 19 2 8 29
Steve McNair 6 1 21 1 29
C. Pennington 10 11 6 1 28
K. Collins 12 1 12 1 1 27
Carson Palmer 20 1 1 4 26
J. Garcia 2 15 1 8 26
Alex Smith 1 1 18 1 4 25
J. Freeman 11 10 4 25
Jameis Winston 16 1 7 24
Ryan Tannehill 1 7 5 6 2 2 23
Derek Carr 3 8 2 5 4 22
D. Watson 1 1 15 3 20
Jake Delhomme 7 1 2 7 2 19
Tua Tagovailoa 8 1 10 19
Jordan Love 2 5 7 4 18
Jayden Daniels 11 6 17
Baker Mayfield 1 2 3 1 2 7 16
Brian Griese 11 1 3 1 16
Trevor Lawrence 14 2 16
Andrew Luck 1 6 8 15
Daniel Jones 1 1 2 10 1 15
Brock Purdy 4 9 13
Caleb Williams 1 2 1 9 13
Byron Leftwich 1 3 2 6 12
Carson Wentz 1 10 1 12
Drake Maye 1 11 12
Geno Smith 1 2 1 8 12
J. Campbell 1 1 9 1 12
Jake Plummer 7 5 12
Justin Fields 6 2 2 1 11
Kyle Orton 1 6 4 11
Rex Grossman 1 10 11
Blake Bortles 1 3 4 1 1 10
M. Cassel 10 10
Marcus Mariota 1 4 5 10
N. Foles 1 8 9
Sam Howell 9 9
Andy Dalton 5 1 2 8
Drew Bledsoe 7 1 8
Jimmy Garoppolo 5 3 8
Joey Harrington 3 4 1 8
Sam Darnold 3 2 1 1 1 8
Bo Nix 1 6 7
Brad Johnson 1 1 5 7
Colin Kapernick 4 2 6
Gardner Minshew 2 1 1 1 5
Jacoby Brissett 3 1 1 5
M. Leinhart 5 5
Teddy Bridgewater 4 1 5
TJ Edwards 5 5
Vince Young 2 3 5
Case Keenum 1 1 2 4
David Carr 2 2 4
David Garrard 3 1 4
M. Brunell 1 2 1 4
Charlie Batch 1 2 3
CJ Stroud 2 1 3
Josh McCown 2 1 3
K. Kolb 1 1 1 3
P. Ramsey 3 3
R. Fitzpatrick 1 1 1 3
Sam Bradford 1 1 1 3
Shaun Hill 2 1 3
Tim Couch 3 3
Anthony Richardson 1 1 2
Billy Volek 2 2
Bryce Young 1 1 2
C. Painter 1 1 2
D. Huard 2 2
Derek Anderson 1 1 2
Gus Ferrotte 2 2
Jake Locker 1 1 2
Jaxon Dart 2 2
JJ McCarthy 1 1 2
JP Losman 2 2
Mac Jones 2 2
Mitch Trubinsky 1 1 2
RG3 1 1 2
Sage Rosenfels 1 1 2
T. Rattay 2 2
Trey Lance 2 2
Tyrod Taylor 1 1 2
Vinny Testerverde 2 2
Bryan Hoyer 1 1
Chad Henne 1 1
Charlie Frye 1 1
Christian Ponder 1 1
Clemons 1 1
Colt McCoy 1 1
Cooper Rush 1 1
Dan Orlovsky 1 1
Davis Mills 1 1
Jim Miller 1 1
JT O’Sullivan 1 1
K. Boller 1 1
Kelly Holcomb 1 1
Kyle Allen 1 1
M. Sanchez 1 1
Mason Rudolph 1 1
R. Mallet 1 1
Shane Matthews 1 1
Tavaris Jackson 1 1
Tommy Maddox 1 1
Trent Dilfer 1 1
Trevor Siemian 1 1
Will Levis 0 1 1
Jeff Blake 0
Mike White 0
T. Huntley 0
Tyler Heinicke 0
Tysom Hill 0

Some random observations…

  • Of eligible managers, only Kaiser and Tansuche, neve started Tom Brady a single game.
  • Similarly, Kronner and Kyle are the only ones without a Drew Brees start in their stats.
  • For Stafford, it’s Matt, Jim and Shaun.
  • Russell Wilson was similarly passed around like the town bicycle, with only Josh refraining a ride.

Top 25 All-Time

These are the most used QBs, not just by us, but adding in all previous managers as well.

Rank QB Active Retired Total
1 Tom Brady 235 41 276
2 Drew Brees 221 2 223
3 Aaron Rodgers 180 3 183
4 Peyton Manning 75 102 177
5 Phillip Rivers 124 30 154
6 Matt Ryan 111 39 150
7 Matthew Stafford 143 0 143
8 Eli Manning 129 9 138
9 Big Ben 104 28 132
10 Patrick Mahomes 100 10 110
11 Brett Favre 106 0 106
12 Donovan McNabb 85 14 99
13 Russ Wilson 85 13 98
14 Tony Romo 74 20 94
15 Lamar Jackson 75 14 89
16 Josh Allen 79 6 85
17 Cam Newton 42 41 83
18 Carson Palmer 26 53 79
19 Dak Prescott 66 12 78
20 Jared Goff 48 30 78
21 Kirk Cousins 38 34 72
22 M. Hasselbeck 51 20 71
23 Andrew Luck 15 51 66
24 K. Warner 62 0 62
25 M. Vick 57 4 61

Goff continues to climb the ladder and should pass Carson Palmer this year. The highest of the active QBs are Rodgers and Stafford. While Rodgers isn’t likely to move up, Stafford could still catch both Matt Ryan before the year ends.

Observations….

Brady remains the most started QB in SCL history with 276 starts.

  • The greatest disparity that I noticed, from one week to the next belongs to Jones. Jon started Billy Volek (I’m sure everyone remembers him!) two weeks in a row. The first game he was rewarded with 548 points, only to be punished for it the next week when Volek put up -24 points.
  • The record for most starts by any QB among current managers goes to Tom Brady (235).
  • The most starts by a QB for an active Manager is Aaron Rodgers for Dave with 98.
  • Most surprising (to me) QB to break 40 starts; Marc Bulger (49).
  • Guys that somehow started more than 10 games; Kyle Orton, Josh Freeman, Rex Grossman

 

And here is what the Champs have looked like…

Year Manager Main QB Final Game QB
2001 Kronner Rich Gannon Rich Gannon
2002 Pete Drew Bledsoe Chad Pennington
2003 Jones Matt Hasselbeck Chad Pennington
2004 Timmy Peyton Manning Peyton Manning
2005 Byrd Carson Palmer Carson Palmer
2006 Kronner Donovan McNabb Joey Harrington
2007 Ryan Drew Brees Drew Brees
2008 Chris Matt Cassel Matt Cassel
2009 Ryan Aaron Rodgers Aaron Rodgers
2010 Josh Matt Schaub Matt Schaub
2011 Jones Tony Romo Tony Romo
2012 Kaiser Michael Vick Andrew Luck
2013 Chris Tony Romo Tony Romo
2014 Trigger Peyton Manning Peyton Manning
2015 Dave Aaron Rodgers Aaron Rodgers
2016 Steve Andrew Luck Andrew Luck
2017 John Tom Brady Tom Brady
2018 Jones Carson Wentz Nick Foles
2019 Kaiser Dak Prescott Dak Prescott
2020 Kyle Tom Brady Tom Brady
2021 Jones Dak Prescott Dak Prescott
2022 Matt Patrick Mahomes Patrick Mahomes
2023 Trigger Lamar Jackson Lamar Jackson
2024 Jones Justin Herbert Bryce Young
“You chodes let me win two fucking championships in here! HAHA”

Observations…

  • Two years in a row (02 & 03), the champs rolled through the season with another QB, but started Chad Pennington in the final to close it out.
  • No QB has ever won more than 2 titles, but there are seven who have done it twice.
  • 2018 marked a mirror of the NFL, as Jones started Wentz most of the year, but started Nick Foles in the championship.